Italy World Cup Qualifiers 2026: Can the Azzurri Avoid Another Heartbreak?

For a nation that has won four World Cups, the idea of missing three in a row is almost too painful to contemplate. Yet that is precisely the shadow hanging over Italian football as the Azzurri navigate their 2026 World Cup qualifying campaign. After failing to reach Russia 2018 and Qatar 2022 — two of the most traumatic episodes in Italian football history — the pressure on Luciano Spalletti and his players is immense. Italy must qualify. The alternative is unthinkable.

The Wounds That Won’t Heal

2018: The Night in Milan

November 13, 2017. San Siro, Milan. Italy needed to overturn a 1-0 deficit against Sweden in the UEFA playoff second leg to qualify for the 2018 World Cup in Russia. What followed was 90 minutes of frustration, anxiety, and ultimately, despair.

Italy dominated possession but created little of substance. Sweden, organized and disciplined under Janne Andersson, defended deep and held firm. The final score: 0-0. Aggregate: 0-1. Italy were out of the World Cup for the first time since 1958 — a gap of 60 years.

The images from that night are seared into Italian football’s collective memory. Gianluigi Buffon, 39 years old and playing what he believed would be his final international match, left the pitch in tears. Daniele De Rossi sat on the bench, head in hands. The Azzurri players stood in disbelief as the reality sank in. The great Buffon would never play at another World Cup.

The fallout was swift and brutal. Manager Gian Piero Ventura was sacked. Carlo Tavecchio resigned as president of the Italian Football Federation (FIGC). An entire generation of Italian players — Buffon, De Rossi, Andrea Barzagli, Giorgio Chiellini (who was injured for the playoff) — saw their World Cup dreams end not with a final bow but with a whimper.

2022: The North Macedonia Humiliation

If missing 2018 was a shock, missing 2022 was a humiliation of a different order. Italy had won Euro 2020 just eight months earlier, beating England in the final at Wembley. Roberto Mancini’s side played some of the most exciting football in Europe, built around Jorginho’s passing, Lorenzo Insigne’s creativity, and a defensive structure that conceded just four goals in seven tournament matches.

But the euphoria of the European Championship masked deeper problems. Italy stumbled through qualifying, failing to win their group after draws against Bulgaria, Switzerland (twice), and Northern Ireland. They were forced into the playoffs.

On March 24, 2022, at the Stadio Renzo Barbera in Palermo, Italy faced North Macedonia in the playoff semi-final. It should have been a formality. North Macedonia, ranked 67th in the world, had never qualified for a World Cup. Italy had 37 shots. North Macedonia had four.

In the 92nd minute, Aleksandar Trajkovski — a journeyman forward playing in the Saudi Arabian league — received the ball 25 yards from goal and unleashed a low, skidding shot that beat Gianluigi Donnarumma at his near post. The stadium fell silent. Italy had lost 1-0 to North Macedonia. They would miss a second consecutive World Cup.

The result was described as the worst in Italian football history. Mancini initially stayed on but eventually resigned in August 2023, his faith in the project shaken. The FIGC was plunged into crisis. Italian football — its structures, its youth development, its coaching philosophy — was subjected to soul-searching examination.

Euro 2020: The Redemption That Wasn’t Enough

Italy’s Euro 2020 triumph (held in 2021 due to COVID-19) was one of the great stories in European football. Under Mancini, the Azzurri played with a freedom and attacking intent that was almost un-Italian in its ambition. The 4-3-3 system, built around the midfield excellence of Jorginho, Marco Verratti, and Nicolo Barella, produced flowing, dynamic football.

The tournament run was magnificent: a 3-0 demolition of Turkey in the opener, a tense extra-time victory over Austria in the Round of 16, a dramatic penalty shootout win over Spain in the semi-final, and then the final at Wembley — where Leonardo Bonucci equalized after Luke Shaw’s early goal, and Italy prevailed in a penalty shootout that saw Bukayo Saka, Jadon Sancho, and Marcus Rashford miss for England.

But the Euro 2020 squad was already aging. Bonucci was 34, Chiellini was 36, Insigne was 30. The transition to the next generation was mishandled, and the failure to qualify for the 2022 World Cup exposed the fragility beneath the European Championship triumph. The lesson was clear: winning a tournament and building a sustainable national team are two very different things.

The Spalletti Era

Luciano Spalletti was appointed as Italy’s head coach in September 2023, inheriting a squad in flux and a nation’s expectations on his shoulders. The 65-year-old Tuscan, who had just led Napoli to their first Serie A title in 33 years with a record-breaking 90-point season, was tasked with restoring Italian football’s credibility on the world stage.

Tactical Evolution

Spalletti’s approach has been a departure from Mancini’s. Where Mancini favored a 4-3-3 built on possession and pressing, Spalletti has been more pragmatic, adapting his system to the players available. He has experimented with a 3-5-2, a 4-2-3-1, and a 3-4-2-1, seeking the right balance between defensive solidity — the traditional Italian virtue — and the attacking dynamism that modern football demands.

The emphasis on a high defensive line, aggressive pressing triggers, and quick transitions has given Italy a more vertical dimension. Spalletti’s Napoli were one of the most exciting teams in European football, and he has sought to transplant some of that philosophy to the national team — though the limited time available for international managers makes this a perpetual challenge.

Euro 2024: A Reality Check

Italy’s defense of their European Championship at Euro 2024 in Germany was a sobering experience. The Azzurri scraped through the group stage, needing a 98th-minute equalizer from Mattia Zaccagni against Croatia to progress. They were then comprehensively beaten 2-0 by Switzerland in the Round of 16, a performance that laid bare the squad’s limitations.

The tournament exposed several issues: a lack of world-class attacking options, defensive vulnerability without the retired Bonucci and Chiellini, and a midfield that — despite Barella’s excellence — lacked the collective quality of the Euro 2020 vintage. Spalletti faced criticism but was retained, with the FIGC viewing stability as essential to the World Cup qualifying campaign.

The 2026 Qualifying Campaign

Italy’s qualifying group has presented a test of character and quality. The UEFA qualifying format for 2026 features 12 groups — some of four teams, some of five — with the group winners qualifying directly and the runners-up entering a playoff round. With 16 European spots available (up from 13 in 2022), the pathway is slightly more forgiving, but for Italy, anything other than direct qualification would be seen as failure.

Group Dynamics

Italy’s qualifying group has pitted them against familiar European opponents. The matches have been a mixture of professional efficiency and frustrating inconsistency — a pattern that has characterized Italian qualifying campaigns in recent cycles.

Home matches at the Stadio Olimpico in Rome and various other Italian venues have seen strong attendances, with the Italian public rallying behind the Azzurri despite the recent disappointments. The away fixtures — always testing in European qualifying — have required the tactical discipline and game management that Italian football is built on.

Key Results and Moments

The qualifying campaign has had its share of drama. Early results set the tone, with Spalletti’s tactical adjustments proving decisive in several tight matches. The ability to grind out results — a hallmark of Italian football at its best — has been tested repeatedly.

Italy’s home form has been crucial. The Olimpico has been a fortress in recent qualifying campaigns, and Spalletti has leaned heavily on the atmosphere generated by the Italian supporters. But it is the away results that will likely determine whether Italy qualify directly or face the playoff lottery that has been so cruel to them in recent history.

Key Players

Gianluigi Donnarumma (Goalkeeper, Paris Saint-Germain)

The man who saved Saka’s penalty to win Euro 2020 remains Italy’s undisputed number one. At 27, Donnarumma is in the prime of his career, combining shot-stopping ability with the composure and distribution that modern goalkeeping demands. His PSG experience — playing behind a high line against Europe’s best — has sharpened his game. Donnarumma’s leadership and big-game mentality are essential to Italy’s hopes.

Nicolo Barella (Midfielder, Inter Milan)

Italy’s most important outfield player. Barella is a complete midfielder — box-to-box, technically excellent, tactically intelligent, and capable of producing decisive moments in the biggest matches. His ability to carry the ball through midfield, his passing range, and his late runs into the box make him the engine of Spalletti’s system. At 29, he is at the peak of his powers and carries the expectation of a nation.

Sandro Tonali (Midfielder, Newcastle United)

Tonali’s return from a betting-related suspension was one of the most anticipated storylines in Italian football. The former AC Milan midfielder, who moved to Newcastle in 2023 before being banned for 10 months, brings a different dimension to Italy’s midfield — tenacity, aggression, and an ability to win the ball back that complements Barella’s more creative instincts. His rehabilitation has been a personal and professional journey, and his performances since returning have been vital.

Mateo Retegui (Striker, Atalanta)

The Argentine-born forward, who qualifies for Italy through his Italian ancestry, has emerged as the Azzurri’s first-choice striker. His goalscoring instincts, aerial ability, and willingness to press from the front have made him Spalletti’s preferred option in the central attacking role. Retegui’s goal record in qualifying has been impressive, and his integration into the team — despite initial skepticism about his Italian credentials — has been one of Spalletti’s successes.

Federico Chiesa (Forward, Liverpool)

When fit, Chiesa remains one of Italy’s most dangerous attacking players. His pace, dribbling, and directness can unlock defenses, and his Euro 2020 performances — including a brilliant goal against Austria — showed his capability on the biggest stage. However, injuries have hampered his career, and his availability for the qualifying campaign has been inconsistent. When he plays, he transforms Italy’s attack; when he doesn’t, the Azzurri lack a cutting edge.

Riccardo Calafiori (Defender, Arsenal)

The young defender, who moved to Arsenal from Bologna, has established himself as a key figure in Spalletti’s backline. His composure on the ball, ability to play out from the back, and aerial dominance have made him a modern defender in every sense. Calafiori’s partnership with other young defenders represents the future of Italian defensive football — a tradition that must be maintained if Italy are to succeed.

The Pressure on the FIGC

The Italian Football Federation (FIGC) and its president Gabriele Gravina are under enormous pressure. Two missed World Cups have had commercial, cultural, and political consequences. Sponsorship revenues have declined, fan engagement has wavered, and the Italian government has questioned the federation’s governance.

The structural issues run deep. Italian youth development, once the envy of Europe, has fallen behind. The conveyor belt that produced Maldini, Pirlo, Cannavaro, and Buffon has slowed. Serie A’s financial constraints have limited investment in academies, and the influx of foreign players has reduced opportunities for young Italians.

The FIGC’s response has included investment in grassroots football, coaching education, and infrastructure. But these are long-term projects; the immediate need is to qualify for the 2026 World Cup, and the pressure on every stakeholder — from the federation president to the coaching staff to the players — is immense.

What Italy Need to Do

The path to qualification is straightforward in theory: win the group. Direct qualification avoids the playoff minefield that has proved so treacherous. Italy’s squad, while not as star-studded as the Euro 2020 vintage, has the quality to top a European qualifying group.

The key factors are:

1. Defensive organization: Italy’s defensive record must be near-impeccable. Clean sheets win qualifying campaigns.
2. Barella’s fitness and form: Everything runs through the Inter Milan midfielder. His availability is non-negotiable.
3. Goalscoring consistency: Retegui must continue to deliver. Italy cannot rely on 1-0 victories alone.
4. Away discipline: The ability to take points on the road — through tactical discipline, game management, and mental fortitude — will likely be decisive.
5. Avoiding complacency: The lessons of 2018 and 2022 must be learned. Every match is a potential banana skin.

The Weight of History

Italy’s World Cup history is glorious: four titles (1934, 1938, 1982, 2006), six finals, and a tradition of defensive excellence that has defined the sport. But the last eight years have been a dark chapter. Missing two World Cups is an embarrassment for any major football nation; for Italy, with their history and expectations, it is a crisis.

The 2026 qualifying campaign is more than a series of football matches. It is a referendum on the state of Italian football, a test of whether the nation that gave the world catenaccio, libero, and some of the greatest players in history can find its way back to the game’s biggest stage.

For Spalletti, for Barella, for Donnarumma, for every Italian player who pulls on the Azzurri shirt, the message is clear: there is no margin for error. Italy must be at the 2026 World Cup. The nation demands it, the history requires it, and the football world expects it.

Whether they can deliver remains the question that haunts Coverciano, the FIGC’s technical center in the Tuscan hills, and every piazza where Italians gather to watch their national team. The answer will define a generation.

FIFA Watch Editorial will provide comprehensive coverage of Italy’s qualifying campaign, including match previews, tactical analysis, and squad updates.

---

Sources: FIFA.com, UEFA.com, FIGC.it, Opta, Transfermarkt, La Gazzetta dello Sport, Corriere dello Sport, The Athletic.